October 21, 2008

are some blogs too nicey nice?

Messy desk

Grab a cup of tea, or coffee, or better yet a glass of wine, as this is a long one.

My last post opened quite an interesting discussion, so interesting in fact that it inspired another one for today. You could say that the change I have spoken about over the last couple of months has finally settled in and I’m feeling myself again but from a completely new vantage point, especially in relation to this blog I keep. Honestly, I’ve had a few things on my mind that I’ve been meaning to share, so here goes.

It wasn’t until I read Ellen’s comment yesterday when she referred to blogs as being too "nicey nicey" that I knew what I wanted to say. Now let me take a moment, following my own advice to make sure this is coming from the "right" place that I spoke about yesterday, otherwise I might be a hypocrite and I definitely don’t want to be that. :)

You see I studied Improv for a solid two years, and one of the main lessons of Improv, and all comedy really, is to state the obvious. Usually the obvious is what’s funny and often times the obvious is what people won’t readily discuss.  This is probably one reason we have that famous saying, "there’s a pink elephant in the room". Since my days of Improv I chose to assimilate this idea of stating the obvious into my every day life. And this is because I find my life is so much easier in the long run when I "state the obvious", mostly because for me it’s just too much work trying to  continuously cover things up, and then remember what needs covering up, and then...you get the idea.

When I first became interested in blogging it was just two and half years ago now. And the reason this interest turned into a passion for this new medium was because it felt like the most honest expression I had come across in a long time, what seemed to me to be a truly authentic slice of people’s lives. In light of all the over-styled lives presented in traditional media, blogs felt like a breath of fresh air, so real and genuine (still edited of course) but with an individuality that was and in many cases still is so refreshing to visit ~ as you get to "know" the people behind them a little more all the time. Blogs provide a glimpse into the lives of people and how it might really be for them day to day. Blogs give us a chance to be inspired by people that feel more "real" than other public personas, ie celebrities in television and film, and those featured in magazines who have an entire crew of people working to make their lives look like what someone else thinks is the "ideal life". Believe me I know, I’ve worked in front of and behind the camera since I’ve been in Hollywood and I had a huge eye opening about what actually goes on behind the scenes to create an image that I once perceived was to some degree real. Nope not the case, well maybe if you had about 20 people obsessing over only you every day. I digress.

Alright I’ve prefaced this enough. What I’m trying to say is that I’m simply no longer willing to ignore the obvious as I see it in much of the blogging world that I follow. Many (not all) blogs, and I narrow this down to the creative/artisan/crafting/design blogging world, are in my opinion losing their individuality. They just don’t feel genuine anymore, let alone honest. And to use Ellen’s phraseology, I agree that many are just feeling too "nicey nicey" ~ and I’m going to go ahead and include my blog in that mix. It goes without saying that in no way or shape or form am I suggesting being rude is or unkind is what needs to happen with the blogging world. Good Lord, no. Of course being nice, supportive, inspiring and uplifting is a wonderful way to be in the world in general let alone the blogging world. And these qualities continue to dominate this blogging niche that I follow and am proud to be a part of.

But there are times, when it feels like too much. It sometimes feels like blogs are no longer being written from a unique perspective, but instead being written as if they are competing to win a popularity contest. Sometimes sweetness is being pushed to the limit and it fees like saccharin, not sugar. Don’t get me wrong, I love sweetness and I love a happy life, I live one, and I love to spread the message of that, but even in a happy creative life there are challenges. And it’s disappointing. It’s disappointing to me that what I thought was a more authentic medium, as it gains popularity is slowly becoming watered down in it’s efforts to gain and keep approval just like all other forms of expression that came before it. This may be because blogging is now also another medium open to advertising, which I think is fantastic. I sincerely think it is great that bloggers can make a living this way. But how can a blogger not be influenced by wanting to keep their traffic numbers in support of their advertisers? I’m just wondering if the number of visitors and comments a blog gets is beginning to define blogs vs simply being creative outlet to freely express yourself?  And you know, I can see how this can happen and does happen all the time in all forms of creative expression. I’m not complaining and I’m not criticizing ~ and of course in line with yesterday’s topic regarding value and pricing, I’m not in any position to say whether anyone is being truly authentic or not. I don’t really know. There’s not a right way or wrong way to blog and there’s room for all kinds of "voices' out there. I’m just observing and saying what I see, expressing what works and no longer works for me. And since it was brought up in yesterday’s comments and has been a regular topic among my blogging friends lately, I’m wondering if you see it too?

The reason I am even calling attention to this at all, is because I am wanting to use this in reference to my own blog. So this is about me, no one else, just me!  I think I’ve fallen into this category of blogs at times, still seeking the approval of others, and as my own traffic and customer base has grown, I’ve found myself caring a bit too much about my own popularity and probably being a little artificially sweet on ocassion, to keep the approval coming. But for me it’s time to let the approval seeking go not just here but everywhere, and this is my public statement saying that I do not want to fall into the category of being an inauthentic voice in the world, not personally or professionally. By looking out into the blogging world, the differences I see are helping me to become more clear about what I want this blog to represent, moving forward from here. All I can say is that I am drawn more and more to blogs who over time are consistently themselves, who don’t seem to be keeping a blog to win popularity. It’s possible that as a reader of my blog, you do feel that my blog voice feels consistent, and I have certainly tried to be this, as it’s always been important to me to make this a genuine, albeit edited slice of my life. But I know there are times when I’m not truly being myself here. You see, my desk while often straightened up,  is also incredibly messy sometimes (as in the photo above, taken just this morning)...especially when I am creating. Straight or messy, not one is right or wrong, good or bad, it’s just how it is, I experience them both. And I don’t want to leave one side out of who I am.

It’s almost as if a few blogs lead the way in this niche, and we were inspired. So we all started blogging too and then the few blogs that started first became popular over time. And then we naturally looked at them as examples of "how to blog". Nothing wrong with that, and totally understandable as that is typically how anything new gets developed. Someone starts and we follow. And we can’t help but be influenced by what inspires us. Yet without realizing it we start to look the same, until someone veers from the following and something new begins again. It’s what keeps things fresh and exciting. And then there are those who I am coming to admire more and more, the ones who came to know themselves right away, who evolve in the same way I mentioned above, but they manage to always evolve by consistently staying true to who they are. And this is the age old question, "how can you tell?" ~ I don’t really know, but I think you can just tell. I’ve said it a million times before, but I can appreciate any creation and expression when it feels genuine.  And when you seek to become more genuine yourself, the people who have always been this way begin to come into clear focus.

I think that as I become more of a public persona myself via this blog, there has also been and increase in being overly concerned with how I will be perceived. I also have to say that I have a new found respect for anyone who is in the public eye.  And after yesterday, I finally realized that no matter how much care and thought I give to a post or to how I choose to be in the world, someone out there will interpret it the way I intended and someone else out there will not ~ This was a concept I always knew in theory but have just come to understand in practice.

So if you’ve made it this far, let me repeat and let me try to be clear, the main point of this post isn’t about anyone else, it’s about me and my blog. It’s about defining where I’m wanting to go from here. I’ve always been teetering on the sharing more/versus just sharing and focusing on my work but it appears that I’m feeling drawn to expressing my voice here more and more, (as my "thoughts on things" category is getting a lot of use these days!). It does not mean that my tone to this blog, one that I intend to err on the side of genuine, honest, happiness, hope, support and inspiration is going to change ~ imparting those qualities via my art and my writing is still of utmost importance to me. Nor does it mean that I plan to air all my laundry here, dirty or clean in the name of honesty! It just means that I’m opening the door to what’s next, which I believe will include more of my voice via writing and podcasts. To be honest, part of the reason I’ve been slow on the podcasts is for the same reason. I’ve been concerned about how I would be perceived. My following has grown here, and I haven’t felt entirely ready to go along with that expansion yet. But for some reason on the heels of all this change, I finally do.

At the end of the day, I may be able to manipulate my words in a way to present myself in a certain way, but my art cannot be manipulated in the same way. My paintings are what really started this blog, and they will continue to be one of the best representations of me. My true candor is always present in my paintings. The joy that is in them, that’s me. I really am this happy most of the time. The thoughtfulness that is in them, well no need to explain that one really...also me. The honesty that is in them ~ it’s me. And I want to speak freely more often about what feels honest to me. The humor you see in some of them...sometimes... I actually am funny. ;) The love that is in them ~ and that exists for the work that I do, is something I want to continue to share here at my blog. And the message that you too CAN do it ~ follow your creative dreams or any other dreams for that matter ~ that message will never change.

Well that should about cover it for the time being. Now it’s back to business...as usual...but with a slightly new twist.


Comments (27)

ahhh Marisa its like a breath of fresh air just went onto my computer!! I have had this conversation with a few fellow artist/blogger friends and after one comment I made awhile back on Design Sponge it blew my mind how people would have rather have their *** filled with hot air than reality! I guess because I am an Aries and have always felt honesty is the best policy its hard for me to suck up as they say.

I started a blog myself to show people other projects I am working on and to give my art a voice since most of the time it is licensed on product and I do not know what people think of it.

While its nice to always hear good things about yourself its much helpful to hear comments on what is not working in your design or rather what you could do to improve on it. I love that you have opened this discussion up on your blog, I am now inspired to do the same on mine. As you stated earlier that many blogs do not fell genuine you are soo correct. I would never name names but if some bloggers knew some of the artists I knew whose blog was full of *** they would be shocked! Very shocked. I will keep it to myself of course not to be nicey-nicey but to just point out things aren't always what they seem.

A very big Alleluia to you!!!!
Boy is this "nicey-nicey" world of blogging getting a bit stagnant and boring...I mean come on...there are even awards now for having a NICE blog...not that you want people to be mean, but really, get on board the reality train folks....be truthful, be honest, be forthright about things. I just said this to Ellen today about another blogger who goes on everyone's blog and leaves these sicky sweet messages all the time, so much so, that you know it cannot be genuine, she is just trying to "kiss up" as they say.

your post was quite lengthy, so let me say this....if you want to be honest and truthful about how you feel about something, you have to be prepared for those out there to want to take issue with you about your stand.... I think they call that politics. That is fine. I would almost welcome that more, at least it would make blog land interesting.
I think you just have to be true to yourself, do your artwork, your posts, your life as you see fit and if the others come to like it and follow your blog, great. But, to diminish the honestly and integrity of what you do to please others is not a good idea....

you can't please everyone all the time...so don't even try.

I think you should charge more for your calendar! I bet you could get it too!

I think I will buy one of your wonderful calendars from you today!

have a great day. Perhaps we should have a button made for our blogs that says something like...

Nice is Nice but Honesty is Better.

take care,
carol

best,
carol
Let me say that the photo you posted could have been taken in my studio. :) Creativity and Chaos together=Process, no?

I have to agree with you about the nicey-nicey. I see comments (especially on the "cool kids" blogs) that make gag when I read them...their saccharine worship just irks me. I have a feeling many do this to get reciprocal comments on their own blogs, or to have a feeling (however brief) that they too are part of the "cool kids."

I wish more wrote with your blunt, refreshing honesty. There in no bigger turn on then authenticity. :P I think many bloggers (myself included, esp as a kidlit blogger) get stuck in a rut of a role they're supposed to play. I hope more out there will read this post and realize that high school is over, and the only freedom is in being true to their lives and themselves.

Bravo
Hey Marisa,

I just wanted to say a quick thank you for writing this- I've really enjoyed the thoughtfulness that I've read here the past couple of days, and especially the example of how you turned an experience that could easily turn to blaming someone else and having hurt feelings into an opportunity to grow and re-evaluate and be true and loving to yourself and loving to others as well. You are such an inspiration. :)
Cheers,
Jess
I think that there are blogs too nice, I am never rude with other bloggers or readers but I do not want to be perceived as perfect, I am healthy, happy and lucky but I got over certain sad moments in life that were no so nice. I started to post some different stories once a week, that Saturday I posted La mala hija, which is about my life with my mother I had my doubts, but I do not want to be or be seen as one of THe Stepford Wives.
I do not want to tell anyone how to live but I aspire to inspire people to find beauty in every day life.
I fell the competitive thing too, but there are so extraordinary people blogging and I had received so much support from great bloggers, one of the was you.
I see a deep shift going on in the blogging world - I think a lot of people are feeling this, questioning things, wanting to dig deeper towards what is authentic and meaningful and real. It is interesting that so many people are asking a lot of the same questions, as if some limit has been reached and now a lot of people, in their own quiet ways, are revolting.
I think I've composed a comment and deleted it at least four times now. Maybe this one will stick? I'm just going to come out and say it, even though, judging from the above comments, it might not be such a good idea because it seems like we're on a whole "nice is bad" kick here.

There is way too much importance in our culture (and in art/craft/blogging) placed on being an individual, being true to ourselves, and on staying that way consistently.

It is just flat out impossible to stay the same and evolve at the same time. Isn't it important to experiment with different ways of being and expressing ourselves, even if those ways end up being "nicey nice". If we are trying to be a positive force in the world, but aren't in a particularly kind mood, and we manage to write something kind anyway, is that inauthentic? Does that mean affirmations are really just inauthentic "nicey nice" lists that diminish who we are because they aren't authentic? What about those of us who aren't sure in our voices (creative and otherwise)?

The whole idea of a stable "self" is kind of silly in the first place. Philosophers have been debating the idea for centuries. And what if a "sickly sweet" comment (thanks Carol) IS authentic, after all? Can we ever truly know? Can we really claim to know where another blogger is coming from, what their intentions are, and whether or not they are just trying to "kiss up?" And even if they are, so what? So what if they want to inject a little kindness into a world of suffering? On the other hand, as women we are taught that its better to be nice girls than bitches. Maybe finding equal footing with men means we need to be collective bitches more often. Maybe what the world needs now is more hard-asses? If a blog attempts to be nicey nice, does that reflect on WHO that person is, or does it merely reflect the blog itself, the writing itself?

In all, your post and the comments that followed have filled me with questions about the nature of blogging, the nature of writing, sincerity, understanding, kindness or niceness, and questions about what we reflect out into the world. If authenticity is superior to kindness, does that mean it's better for addicts to carry on willy-nilly and hurtfully with their addictions, or is it better that they try to be kind to their families even when they don't feel like it? I know this example is extreme, but the thought entered my head. It's all about context. In the context of posting things that will be archived for perpetuity, is it better we let it all hang out, possibly to the detriment of our careers? Or is it better we retain a semblance of kindness and nicey-nicenness in a professional manner, or in a manner befitting one who wants to make friends through this medium and is, as well, inspired by others?
Thank you as always for sharing your thoughts!

Of course, it has already stirred more thoughts for me.:)

First I want to say that being unkind is NEVER an option ~ not on my blog in my posts or in comments that I leave on other blogs. Now if an opinion I am expressing is perceived as unkind, as I said yesterday, that is not in my control.

With that said, Susannah I'm especially glad for your comment, because it really brings up the point that so much of everything is perception. And for each of us our perception is in a constant state of change even throughout a single day.

And I also wholeheartedly agree in being a positive force in the world. I don't think anyone here is questioning that. And of course there are many bloggers who are wonderful at that.

I also think that words like "genuine", and "authentic" mean different things to different people ~ even more that we can interpret differently :) so it's really hard to answer your question about authenticity vs. kindness. In my definition when you are being authentic, coming from a secure place within yourself, kindness is the natural state of being and I would suggest that any kind of harm or addiction does not stem from that place of authenticity, although people use the word a lot to describe and justify unkind or unhealthy behavior. In the same way that honesty is often used to disguise being unkind.

It is important to say here that I believe that being honest and being kind should go hand and hand.

There is just a present trend in blogging that I am calling into question in myself. And will this post be my final evolution? Absolutely not. We never stay the same ~ but there is a consistency simply in acknowledging that fact alone. Personally I'm just looking to trust myself more and leave a lot what everyone else "thinks" out of the mix.

My mom always taught me, as Carol mentioned in the comment above that "you can never please everyone", and at the end of the day you have to look at yourself in the mirror and if you are happy with with who you are ~ then that is the very best you can do.
I agree with you about the nicey niceness. It doesn't always feel real, or even achievable. I read some blogs, and logically I know that their lives aren't as joyous and perfect as they portray, but it isn't really that inspiring to see perfection, for me. Perfection in a photo or project or a relationship. To me, it's inspiring to see people's journey through the hardship and the successes.

I want REAL creativity, and that's inspiration on top of struggle. Sometimes I have even felt your blog was a little nicey, leaving me feeling shut out of a dialog because you seemed to have it all. But I've always found that piece here that has kept me coming back. Thoughtful words. Inspiration. Openness... not only to creativity or to happiness or to beauty, but also to reality and struggle.

I don't think it means we need to be mean to people. I hate that about the internet. I think real love comes with honesty, and honesty is sometimes ugly. But isn't that ugliness so beautiful?
Marisa, you've had some great discussions the last couple of days. I have to applaud you for going where no blogger has gone before.
I too have read plenty of sickly sweet comments and posts on blogs, or in the Etsy forums (YUCK!). You know the kind that make you throw up a little bit in your mouth? I on the other hand, I have a real dry humor that I have to keep in check regularly so not to offend unintentionally. Someday, when I get the courage to start my own blog, I promise to raise a few eyebrows, not to be hurtful in any way, just honest with myself and my audience (friends,family).
I also believe that a person has several voices. We use a different tone and dialect when we're on the phone, one for when we talk to strangers or give customer service, and one for our husbands and friends. I know that when I'm teaching my art classes, I sound different to an adult than I do a child student. I also notice that when I send emails, I have to edit a lot because I naturally want to write a run on sentence that could break worlds records. Why do I do this, I don't know.
So keep on doing what you do. Your blog is one that I read regularly and look forward to. I mean that sincerely. I could have said " you're just the sweetest, kindest, cutest bloggy blogger ever! Hee! Hee! I couldn't resist. Karin

www.karingrow.etsy.com
great post, marisa. it definitely got me thinking.

for me, i think my blog follows me in an authentic way. sometimes i'm more open, more vulnerable and perhaps more authentic and other times i'm more closed and stay on the surface. and i'm like that in my day to day life too...some days more open, some more closed.

but i do think about that desire to be liked. it certainly comes up for me and it's uncomfortable, so i go between feeling that way and letting it go. again and again.

i felt that "nicey-nice" comment, that being annoyed when i see it in others and when i see it in myself. sometimes nicey-nice is genuinely how you're feeling, but it's definitely interesting to think about when it's not. so thanks for making me think about it some more!
Let me start by saying that I agree with the idea that many blogs & blog comments have fallen into the sticky sweet trap. And that some bloggers are just seeking positive validation and are offended or hurt by constructive comments. The reality is that we artists MUST have thick skins to survive. When I was in college, while others skipped the day, or left their work and quickly slunk out of the room, critique days were my favorite. It offered me a chance to learn and grow. To this day I welcome constructive comments and thoughts ~ I don't know it all (and never will) and a fresh eye can be helpful. I don't have to agree with them, but sometimes it makes me all that much better to have heard the comments.

I don't live an idyllic artist's life...oh wait...maybe I do to some degree. I think the fact that I haven't had a "real" job in many years and still make a good living while alternately working my tail off and having free time in the middle of the day is all pretty good, great even. However, I do not have children and I still don't have time to keep the house immaculate, create & sell a crazy amount of art and whip up a zillion crafts for each holiday. However, careful planning ahead could make it look that way. This is what magazines do ~ their issues filled with the latest holiday crafts weren't done that month. So, I won't look down on anyone who presents the illusion of a "perfect" existence. Maybe they're just good planners and delegators. I say, more power to 'em! They're selling an image.

Quoting Sarah from Spiral Creek >>....is it better we let it all hang out, possibly to the detriment of our careers?<< This comment goes to the heart of my thoughts about this subject. When I was in advertising many years ago, I had a colleague who could be very negative about everything; because she & I were close (and still are) I fell right in with her attitude. I remember sitting in a meeting and she made one of her typical negative comments on a (not present) client's idea. Everyone in the room was looking at her in a way I never wanted people to look at me. From that minute forward, I changed my negative attitude to a more positive one and discovered that this was a wonderful tool for success ~ this does not mean that I became sugary sweet and agreed with everything everyone said. I simply tried to look at the positive side of each situation and if there was none, how could I (I) make it work anyway. This takes SO much less energy than being negative. I am no Pollyanna, as those who know me know, but I have been accused of trying to be everybody's friend. Not true, I simply choose to take the high road as often as possible, and most importantly, as politely and professionally as possible. This isn't always possible and I have gotten tough when I needed to.

I started a blog party because all my art buddies were doing it and it seemed like fun, but more than anything, to promote myself and my work. I have yet to actually "open up" on my blog as I just am not sure that is what I wish to present. This is a business forum of sort for me. As I said above, I am often time pressed as is everyone else and the last thing I wanted to do was take on another task. This blog had to have purpose. Bottom line, for me, this (blog) is mostly business and I seek to present myself (mostly) as I would in a meeting with clients.

Does this mean I am not being "real" or unauthentic?
I won't know what to say here for a few days; It takes me a while to mull things over before forming an opinion. I think that is part of why blogs and comments are so sweet sometimes. Everything moves so fast that we don't take the time to say what we mean, or to even think about a piece of art before commenting on it.
Yes, yes, a million times yes! I've been following this discussion for the past few days, and I have to say that I really appreciate when you initiate these, shall I say, meta discussions. I learn a lot from your writing and from the comments.

For what it's worth, there are many design/art/craft blogs that I glance at without reading, because they tend to have no critical discussions of any sort. That's not bad; it's still a way for me to find some inspiration, but I really do crave more than just eye candy. I read some blogs that are more tangential but offer more food for thought. It's hard to find one that offers both, and I think you're right in pointing out some of the pressures and reasons for that.

Another thought is that, in my opinion at least, it's more important to be respected than necessarily liked. I can think of so many people who are my "heroes" in some way, even though they may not seem entirely nice, friendly, or what have you.

Of course, it's ideal to be all of those things, but plenty of creative people don't have the easiest of personalities to deal with, and I think that comes with the territory. Often, I learn more from people [artists, writers, whoever] who are contrarian and offer me a new perspective, than I do from people who are in the business of blowing sunshine up the... you know what.

I'm looking forward to reading where this discussion goes next, and I hope you'll continue to ask difficult questions.

Maya
VisuaLingual
http://visualingual.wordpress.com
Very interesting thoughts. I'll add simply, that if I don't have something nice, positive and supportive to offer, then I don't comment at all. If someone put their work out there and specifically asked for constructive criticism, then yes, I may be inclined to offer mine. Kindness should never be taken for granted, and finding ways to express yourself with kindness is a good thing. On the subject of honesty, I simply cannot be untrue. (My husband actually thinks I'm too honest!) But if my honesty is going to hurt someone, I've learned over the years to keep it to myself.

Thanks again Marisa for caring enough about this blogging community to put this topic out there for all of us to ponder. Its been very enlightening.
Yes and yes, and yes again. That words: authentic, and authenticity, has been taking top spot in my mind for many months now. I think about it a lot, when I am creating, when I am interacting, when I am reviewing, and when I am writing. It is a word that goes hand in hand with honesty. They are both things that can be a challenge, can be difficult, can feel insurmountable, and yet, in my mind, they keep rising to the surface again and again.

Thank you for your open and honest words, and the topics that you have raised about the blogging world/community, it has been something that seems to be much on peoples minds these days... which usually means there are some folks wanting some change... which means it will come, and then we will have some new topics/issues to think on.
I think this can be the bad thing about blogging: not everyone is good at writing articulately about what they are thinking, so a comment can be misconstrued. As for the "nicey-nice", I think that it is true, but it takes a lot for someone to put themselves out there and many do sincerely try to support one another in their endeavors. I think maybe sometimes we can over-think and over-analyze, so much so that we lose sight of the point. Blogs are meant to be a way for us to express ourselves...There have been blogs that I've stopped reading because the blogger's life seemed too perfect and I found myself wary of that...but does that say something about the blogger or me? We can always focus our attention somewhere else if a blog isn't "doing it" for us. I look to A LOT of blogs for inspiration, and fortunately, I find that on a day-to-day basis...for which I am very thankful. :)
Marisa, I adore what you shared today. I've been blogging since Jan 06... and I"ve loved it.. I'm an upcoming author, and came across you from Blurb, and I've already recommended ur book to a friend of mine with a little boy, ur work is so beautiful. I'm a creative soul just like you! I am a photography nut, I"m a writer, A scrapbooker and more! I just recently selfpublished my own blurb book with Volume 1 of some of my photos plse take a look! see here, http://www.blurb.com/bookstore/detail/390300 I"m so very excited.. I see you have it listed in your etsy shoppe as well.. .has this been profitable for you? Just curious.. plse let me know! I'd love to chat with you sometime.. I adore you already! hugs, bonnierose from Fargo ND
Thank you thank you thank you!
In the last year I have cut down my own blog reading because of this very thing - the artificiality of some of it.

More recently I have noticed a change in myself - I haven't been as inspired to upkeep my blog nearly as much as I used to. Some weeks I'll blog every day and others... well others I just don't have anything "appropriately artsy" going on so I don't say anything. I keep a personal pen & ink journal as well and I've always found it a balance to know what needs writing where. I've put up an internal veil thinking that no one will want to read about my struggles. But so what? What if those very same struggles help just 1 single person get through some struggles of their own? Then it doesn't matter one bit if I'm forever in the depths of a nearly-readerless blog. I write it to write. I write it to catalog my personal progressions and I love it.

Thank you Marissa - as always your blog strikes true to me and it continues to remain one of the few I still read.
One of the things I like best about your blog/podcasts is that you have shared in such an authentic way. I really enjoyed the posts/podcasts you have written about money and also your story (your whole creative story of how you got to be here)
I also like when you share what you have been reading or listening to.

Keep sharing please!
XO,
melba
Dear Marisa,

This post is interesting to read. I'd like to add my opinion if I may, as a blog who has blog ads perhaps my opinion may potentially matter.

I think that having ad space on a blog is no different than showing the products that one makes and sells on their blog. Let me illustrate.

You 'market' your art on Creative Thursday and blogs with ads are marketing their talent and ability as finders, researchers, sifters, and of course writers. Design bloggers who are pros spend an average of 8-16 hours a day on their blogs, read hundreds of emails daily, it's nonstop. For instance, I do not make art, I do not draw or paint for a living. I earn money writing for both publications and also via writing on blogs, Real Simple compensates me to write on their blog and decor8 'sponsors' or advertisers pay to place an ad on my site - an opportunity that small business owners appreciate very much because they often cannot afford to advertise in traditional print publications and they are looking for increased exposure so they can support their small business.

I write for a living. I think saying that blogs with ads are almost to be 'questioned' as their content may be watered down or affected by having advertisers present is like saying that artists with blogs who talk about their art should be questioned for sharing their work because isn't their 'sharing' just another word for self promotion and marketing in a sweeter package? Could they be sharing for selfish reasons - to get noticed by magazines, big stores, to gain licensing opps, etc.? Are they REALLY blogging because they love their customers or are they blogging to nicely and in a smart disguise, to throw product up in their readers faces to make money? Of course, I think that line of reasoning is absolute crap but I'm just saying... a blog that earns money off of ad space is no different to me. A craft/art blog has a product. A design blog with ads has a product (their writing). An interior designer with a blog has a product (their services). Etc. In the end, aren't we all blogging with the intention to promote our work in one form or another? In the beginning I did not blog to earn money from blog ads, back then ads on blogs was rare. Now it's pretty normal to have ads and my reasoning is that if someone wants to pay me to do what I'm showing up to do anyway, that's great!

I do agree that some blogs are into the whole popularity game. But I can only think of a few that fit this category and their are thousands of blogs out there so all in all I think we're doing pretty good as a community at 'keeping it real'.

And do I think being 'too nice' is a problem? Never. Unless it's fake and the person doesn't mean their words. Who I am when I blog is also who I am in person. Those who meet me say this all the time. I'm proud to author a popular blog, I left behind a job in corporate and gave up a lucrative stable job to jump into a career of freelance writing and interior design that I have wanted to do since I was a child. I once cried to my husband that I felt so detached from my cubicle world and that I was normal, I couldn't work a 9 to 5 job, I needed more. I never in my life thought my writing and my blog would become popular but I'm so happy that it has because without the popular blogs I don't think small business would have the same clout and be pushing against big business in the way that it has. I remember before blogs we had Daily Candy to hopefully write about small business. It was the biggest deal in the world if a company was featured on Daily Candy. Now it's a big deal if someone is featured on a popular blog. Many are now earning a living due to a popular blog picking up their work and then their work spread like wildfire on the web.

We live in exciting times I think. I'm absolutely proud to not only be a part of a blogging community but to be around successful bloggers who can earn a living writing blogs and around indie artists and crafters who can also make a living now thanks to blogging and the web. It's a great circle to be a part of and I'm proud of all we've built, together.

I do respect your point and understand that you are going through some shifting lately but please don't lose faith in blogs... I guess we all have to "Remember where we came from". It's easy once things become the norm to forget how we once relied on them so much. If Apartment Therapy didn't write about me when I had 20 readers where would I be today?

Love,
Holly
Hi Marisa, wow!! is all I can say. I haven't checked your blog for a week and I have just spent the last hour catching up on all that has been said on your blog. I have a little opinion that I wanted to share also. I certainly agree with what you say about being honest and genuine on our blogs. I find it's sometimes a fine line however on how much I portray personal feelings on my blog. I am similar to you in that I love all the self improvement stuff and I love sharing with friends etc and from time to time on the blog. But I think that when a blog is attached to a business or website that it needs to be somewhat professional especially from the point of view that customers may not want to read all the personal thoughts. So these are just my feelings and I often hold back for this reason on being totally open and honest. I guess a way around it would be to start a personal blog but the thought of maintaing two blogs is too much effort. Having said that though I love to read your blog and enjoy your heartfelt comments and honesty and other blogs that are similar to yours and that are honest and open with their lives. I guess I am still sitting on the fence with this one. Sorry for the long comment but I have had these thoughts swirling around for a while as well. Have a great day!! Anna
interesting post. i'm fairly new to your blog [and the blogging community as a whole, really] and find these sorts of topics/issues to be quite interesting, especially being more of an observer rather than a participant.
this discussion continues to be really interesting! i am relatively new to blogging and i've read a couple of posts along the way that give pointers on how to do the craft blogging thing – there seems to be unwritten or even written rules about how to do it and i guess most of them are the basic social interaction rules we should follow off blogs.
and, i've not seen any examples of frank discussions of people's creations so far in terms of people offering constructive criticism. so i wonder if there is any honest discussion going on that could be of help to the blogger author, that could help them grow with their work?? tricky territory i guess, but wouldn't it be great! and the ideal would be that comments are from people that respect and like the artist/maker in the first place, so no nastiness would be involved!
from what i've read or listened to on your blog marisa i've really only ever thought that you are honest! to share what you do on your podcasts in the way that you do seems genuine, positive, honest and accessible. it's great, thanku.
Hi Marisa,
I came across your blog the other day because I happen to be a Marisa too, and as we are a rare breed, I had to say hello.
I'm back to blogging after six months away, and I am definitely happy to be writing again, but I am not totally sold on whether plunging back into the blog world is the healthiest thing for me. I mostly write about this quest for spirit and wisdom that I find myself perpetually chasing down. As I am trying to relate to some sense of my "True Self" it started to seem rather antithetical to ask for attention and the praise that would presumably go with it. In this attempt to move beyond the ego I was drawn into self-obsessed blog stat checking, hoping that someone out there was actually reading.
Finding your post when I am really interrogating the position that blogging should take in my writing and spiritual life has been really helpful. If there is truth to speak and honesty to spread, I guess I will keep going, if I find myself caught in some recognition spiral I think it is time for some more off-line introspection.
Blessings,
Marisa, The Girl Who Cried Epiphany (for the sake of clarity!)
Really interesting post, I'm just catching up right now. I enjoyed reading what Holly had to say in the perspective of having ads on a blog and that selling writing with ads is no different from selling art on the blog. I agree wholeheartedly with this. This notion of "selling" (whatever type of selling you are doing) is important I think.

This brings me to what I was thinking while reading, which is of course many art blogs are prone to becoming too nicey nice! When customers are reading it puts the artist in the corner. She suddenly feels like she needs to SELL her blog and the personality behind it. To sell the blog is to sell herself which is to sell the art. It is all connected, because it is all "you".

It is hard to feel comfortable posting about how crappy and negative you feel about something and then follow it up with, "Oh, here is my cute, happy new piece of art! Buy it in my shop." The artist thinks that the customer only WANTS happy because they are BUYING happy, which in the case of your work or my work is probably what drew them to it in the first place. So it is a bit of a quandary for the artist blogger that uses a blog to promote work like you and I and many others do and reaches a customer audience.

On the one hand, the whole person is really important - the good and the bad - so when your blog transforms into one of your creations (which your has) it is hard to feel fulfilled if you aren't able to fully express yourself in the same level as you do with your artwork. On the other hand, since the blog is also a promotional marketing tool, it is really difficult to make that leap and feels safer for many to just write what they think people want to hear.

Speaking as a reader of blogs, I really LIKE to hear it all. The good and the bad. The controversial too. Things like politics for example...why are so few people writing about politics on their personal art blogs? (you did mention it recently and it was a breath of fresh air, good for you) Is it because they are afraid that their customers are voting the opposite way so they leave it out? For some, it is a huge part of their life and the way they live their life...yet they are totally silent on this. This is an example that, as a reader, I'd like a little more honesty and a little more guts.

I'm preaching about all this, but I'm not sure if I practice it either. I try to be honest (and in the example of the Podcast I did with you I worry that I'm TOO honest, too harsh) but admit that often when I don't have anything wonderful to write about my blog stays silent. This is sad and it is almost like a fear that if we present our WHOLE selves we will be rejected. Hmmmmm. A lot to ponder.

So, you've once again totally inspired me to look at my own blog critically.
I have to say kuddos to you for writing this post. I recently was obsessing over my stat counter when it hit me like a brick.... really and truly, the blog is for me. A record of my artistic journey. My thoughts on the process. I was afraid to post pictures of my children the other day when in actuality they were what was inspiring me at the time. So I did it. And it felt good. I always look to your blog for inspirational words. For your journey through life and all its' happiness oozzes through to my little studio here in Georgia. And I thank you.