July 25, 2008

too many birds and bears in the art world?

Me_painting

And are you challenging yourself as an artist?

It was not my Friday morning plan to write a long blog post, but I couldn’t help myself. I was over at Holly’s blog this morning and saw a post she wrote yesterday, about the recent tea towel show I was in. Within the comments is a very interesting discussion going on in response to a comment from Pippa Rex. And I felt compelled to share it here with you and also offer up my thoughts on this subject, as I was one of the artists in this show with bears and birds and cuteness in my creations. And really you might wonder about this yourself in regards to my style of creating and also in the art world in general. It’s a really wonderful topic and another reason I love blogging so much, because we get to have these kinds of honest and insightful "talks" with one another in such an open forum.

So here goes, a very long post for today. The comment from Pippa Rex:

"Now I am not just talking about these tea towels but I have to finally say this as you finished your post by talking about the risks taken in the art world. Does it not bother you that most of the "art" posted here and on other design blogs is all the same. It seems to me that there is an awful lot of silhouette trees and birds, childlike drawings of little girls and bears etc and they are all done by various artists. I guess that I think that there is little risk there. I read your post about how peoples houses are all becoming silimarly decorated (How many "Keep calm and carry on" posters can this world handle? I feel the same is true of this "art" world. When did art stop being controversial or at least personnal. Is this form of art really not just craft?"

My response:

"Hi Holly ~ thanks so much for sharing and Maya, again thanks for inviting me to participate in this show. I am truly loving this discussion via the comments. So thanks to, to Pippa for bringing it up.

Since I am one of the artists of the show and you can clearly see my towel in the images above with both a bear and a bird (and good lord, another owl!) on it and cuteness just dripping from it, I feel inspired to share my thoughts here.

The funny thing for me is that a) I never thought I would make a living as a painter and b) I never at all thought about letting "cuteness" especially with animals be my subject matter. In fact one of my favorite stories to tell is that my photography teacher in college told me once that "cute doesn’t sell". The style that I presently work in developed all on its own. I just remember trying to paint a character for a show theme a group of us had almost 3 years ago now and that was so much fun, it inspired me to go further, and challenge myself with creating characters, because it was something I didn’t think I could do. Then through the process of daily painting more and more of them literally kept appearing in my paintings.

It was like a creative faucet had turned on and it couldn’t stop. And I would ask myself the same question, "I mean really, can I paint another bear or a bird?" but the truth is I couldn’t help myself. And looking back at my childhood and what I created even then, the attraction to cute has been there from the beginning. And every time I try to push myself in a new direction, it feels forced. So these kinds of childlike drawings embodying a certain innocence, joy, hopefulness, simplicity~ they represent the truest part of me right now at this time in my life.

From a small business perspective, it is convenient that these themes are trendy right now. I have even been asked by galleries to paint them because they are "what sells". And I have to be honest and say that as an artist who makes a living with their art, I am always walking that fine line of, "is this my true inspiration and is this something that will sell?". So there is a part of me that wants my work to sell because I love what I do so much and I want to keep doing it, and there is a part of me that is always trying to challenge myself and ask the questions you are asking, especially because I pride myself on not making decisions based solely on financial survival, and most importantly I also want to keep growing as an artist. Somewhere in the middle is where my creations find their voice.

I am also continuously influenced by the art that inspires me and am often interpreting and incorporating what I see in the world around me, into my own art. I do think that while we see a lot of the same themes as you mentioned with "birds, animals and childlike drawings" in art and featured in the world of design and design blogs ~ there’s a reason that it is received so well. I feel that there is a present theme of happiness, and beauty among many of the artists creating work today, and I think people are in search of more of that in their lives and this kind of work, and the design blogs that feature it are reflecting that back to them. It happens to be the art I personally collect, because I too want more happiness in my every day. And I when I look around my home and feel uplifted by what I see, it feels so good. When I travel the internet and visits beautiful blogs like this one, I feel good. It’s that simple. I just want to feel good more of the time.

I often feel that "controversial" art is from a pushed place of the mass idea that somehow "art isn’t good unless it’s controversial". There are artists for whom controversy is their true voice and you can tell that it’s genuine and compelling and interesting. In the same way that artist’s who paint sweeter, less controversial images are either faking it because it’s popular, or it’s also their true voice. Either way I find that genuine art in any form speaks to most people. And really in regards to taking "risk", ANYONE who is willing to create ANYTHING and share it with the world....now that is truly RISK. Every time I put something I make out into the world, it feels risky to me. Every time I wonder how will this be received? Even writing this comment, I wonder. And then I remind myself that however it is received is ok, and that all I am asking from myself is that I be satisfied with what I put out into the world. I really just want to keep creating from my heart and let that be what continues to call me forward.

Which, in closing I have to say that translating my style and my characters to a tea towel for this show, was challenging and so much fun ~ it opened me up to a whole new world of creating that I am just at the beginning of. "

The photo above is me painting at my grandparents home in Germany, when I was 15. I loved it then, and I love it now. And you see I’m painting roses. :)

Comments (15)

This is funny, because I just saw that post and left a comment there. VERY interesting conversation, I think. The web may be changing art, as well as changing media. The whole world, even, because the gatekeepers of the world, the gallery owners and the publishers and the educational institutions are no longer in charge of who gets to be seen and LOVED by the world. I personally get bored by the drive to always be cutting edge. I'd rather see art that was heart felt and deeply thought out than something that was new.

Very interesting, oh yes. I think it's a good thing what Decor8 and you and all the other crafters and designers and artists on the web are doing. I was raised to be an artist, but I turned away from it because I did not want to be a part of the "art world.' It is only now that i feel there is an outlet for my own brand of creativity without submitting to that who's-cooler-than-thou world. Maybe yes, maybe no. We'll see what happens when I try to get my actual art out there. I'm still going in baby steps, but that's okay.
This is a great conversation and it could be talked about for hours. I find that, as a working artist, those things do sell the most. There is a market for the "sweet" and many people are wanting to fill there homes with "sweet" images to surround their family. Myself, I do create art that would fall into this catagory but in my case I am just lucky that it does. I create my art not only because that is what sells but because that is personally what I am drawn to! As an artist I fell that what I create is a product of how I feel and also will change my mood. In school I created more "controversial" art and I realy felt like I was making a statment but it also was draining to me. Even though I create sweet birds and fairytale like art I try to create art that is outside of the box and that has not been seen anywhere else! If you don't create your own spin on things, even if they are sweet images, how else will you be noticed! Thanks for opening up this subject to be talked about!
Melissa
Thanks for sharing this discussion, and your thoughtful response. I'm very impressed that were completely non-defensive, because it is so easy to feel defensive in such situations.

I also wanted to say that I subscribe to your blog (through Google Reader), and the artwork in my house is almost all space and astronomical art. In other words, I don't do "cute." But your art draws me. I might not have been able to articulate why, but your response said it for me: to me your art is "innocence, joy, hopefulness, simplicity". It makes me feel good to look at it.

Thank you.
Great response to the discussion! Bravo for defending your "design voice"
I couldn't have said it better, and love that it came from such a pure, loving place. I especially like how you talked about the "risk". I agree, the scariest risk is the act of putting it out there for the world to see. I know that there is a lot of stuff out there that looks the same. I don't think that is anything new, it is cyclical. Your work however, is unique. You can see through your paintings how talented you are. Never second guess yourself, it would be a great loss for all of us.
Oh goodness, your comments are making me want to say even more :)
thank you so much for sharing your ideas here ~

Rowena ~ the web is definitely changing the world, and especially the creative one. I agree with you wholeheartedly and am so happy that I can find artists that resonate with me directly without the pre-screening of someone who's taste I don't share. I say this a million times too, but it is such an exciting to be an artist ~ And good for you for staying true to your style. You absolutely will find a place and customers for your work when you are ready, and don't ever doubt that.

Melissa ~ I love to hear that you are creating art that is personally what you are drawn to ~i feel the same way and my first interior design boss said "there's never any new ideas ~ people are always re-creating what's been done before" and i say that i agree and that it's really our own spin that makes what any one of us create special. You would think that there would never be a new way to spin an idea, but that will never happen, as long as there are people creating.

Amy ~ thank you. it's an honor to know that my version of cuteness still speaks to you :)

Stephanie ~ as always thank you for sharing your thoughtful voice here ~ i'm so happy to hear that this post isn't reading defensive, because it certainly isn't meant to be and i also don't feel defensive ~ i've asked myself and continue to ask the questions i need to be at peace with who i am and the work i create (on most days :)) ....and once again the work of the inspiring Eckhart Tolle is helping me let go of defending myself. we all have ideas and thoughts, especially on subjective topics like this and i really love hearing them ~ it's all relative too, what we define as controversial or sweet ~ and that's a good thing really. It's so nice that we're different ~ because it's the difference that invites us to be unique
I couldn't agree more with all of you. It's unfortunate that art gets caught up in money because then there will always be people wondering (including the artists themselves) if work is really being created from the heart. I agree that the greatest art tells some truth about the artist and the world he or she lives in and creates every day. My goal in making art is simple-- to give myself a little joy by creating what I find beautiful and interesting, and to hopefully give other people the same joy in seeing a truthful interpretation of what it's like to be alive. I also agree that often art gets too caught up in making a certain type of statement--if a piece of art helps us to appreciating life and let ourselves feel more joy, isn't that a phenomenal success?
Well said, Marisa! Thanks for taking time to write such a thoughtful post. I enjoyed reading it. Cute picture!
All I can say is that I am so glad for blogging artists I would not have found you and I love your art so much. Your pictures make me smile and feel good all day long, everyday.
Thanks so much for reaching out to us and sharing your adorable paintings with us. It's a wonderful way to meet new friends along the way too.

Congratulations for being able to do what you love and to be able to support yourself too.

Hugs,
Karen
I saw that discussion and while her point is valid there is nothing wrong with making "cute" things. Like you said you create from the heart and people respond positively to that. Art is about expressing what you need to express and thank goodness that some of what is out there is cute and fun, we need that just as much, if not more, than "serious" art. Just keep being true to your self. :)
Hi Marisa

What an interesting post. I used to think that to make a living being an artist you either had to create something controversial or dark or be able to paint like an Art Master. Controversial or dark art has never appealed to me and I will never be able to paint like an Art Master so sadly I gave up that dream. When I found Etsy and blogs like yours a whole new world opened up for me and I realized that it's OK to paint what makes me happy and maybe there is even a chance I can make a living from it also. I've learned that being an Artist doesn't mean you have to create something controversial or paint like Picasso-that that's just a stereotype I learned growing up.

I personally don't think cute/fun art that makes people smile will ever go out of fashion. When I choose art to put up in my home I want something that will make me feel happy when I look at it as I am in general a happy person.

Just as you wrote Marisa people want art that speaks to them whether it's a joyful piece or a sad piece - if it's genuine and not forced it will speak to people. And I must also agree with you completely when you say that whenever you put up a new painting on your web or blog it is very nerve racking and it does feel risky as you are opening yourself up for people to judge you and your work. It takes a brave person to do that- it's one of my main fears of working for myself!
Marisa - I'm glad this topic was brought up and the timing couldn't be better. As an artist and part of the Etsy community and growing blogging community I love seeing what's happening in the world of art and craft. But I think what is hard is that the art I create isn't what you may call "popular, modern, or cutting edge." In the back of my head I've wrestled with trying the new popular "cutsy" things and I've played around. But at the end of the day I still find myself being drawn to what I love seeing, painting and thinking about. I'm the one that has to sit before the blank paper for hours so it really needs to be something that I want to see on paper and works the best from me as an artist.
"EVERY ARTIST DIPS HIS BRUSH IN HIS SOUL AND PAINTS HIS OWN NATURE INTO HIS PICTURES." - Henry Ward Beecher
Hi Marisa...what a great topic of conversation. And I will have to check things out over at Decor8 as well.

I find it interesting because in my studying art I found a particular emphasis on "serious" art making. I remember one woman in a class of mine, who was a BRILLIANT illustrator, and she was constantly pushed to express herself "more seriously". She wisely chose to leave the program and pursue illustration. I on the other hand started out wanting to make things that people would like and approve of...which is both difficult and disheartening. And later found that, at that time in my life, a raw and potentially "controversial" voice is exactly what my work needed. And it "needed" it because it was genuine. Where am I now? Probably somewhere in the middle. And that is something I am exploring more. But the primary compass is what "feels right".

I agree that it can be a slippery slope when making market considerations but I do believe at the heart of a successful artist is a genuine and honest expression...be it cute or controversial. I also agree that we're seeing more "happy" art because there is a longing for it on some level. I think you also see this expressed in that more people seem to want to support smaller artists, and farmers, and businesses, etc. I think we want to connect or at least feel connected to something of substance. I think we long for something real, essentially. Cute or otherwise.
This was actually encouraging. I have friends and family asking me why I've started to create stuffies and "cute art" when I was trained so differently. Maybe for me it has to do with expressing my happiest times in childhood. I don't know, really but I will say I've never felt more creative! It's almost like I've lost my validity as an artist in other people's eyes. They think I'm wasting my talent. Sure, I can paint realistically but at the moment it is not where my heart is. I get more joy out of creating little "creatures" than I ever did as a portrait artist or designer. Anyway, thanks for posting this b/c it's something I've been thinking about.
Hey, Marisa. The decor8 discussion went on and on, with many thought-provoking comments. Her blog recently moved, too, and here's the updated link to that post:

http://decor8blog.com/2008/07/24/a-mad-tea-towel-party/

I have two more thoughts to add. One, I do believe that there is some sort of Zeitgeist that guides these visual trends. For instance, the penchant for birds and other nature-themed elements and materials might be traced back to our concern for the environment. If more people are thinking about issues such as their carbon footprint, I think it makes sense that artists also respond in their own way, so you end up seeing more of these similar visual elements. [That's not to discount trend-watching or trend-following, but I think there are more complex and deep-rooted explanations for a lot of these trends.]

Two, there is value in following and examining an artist's work over time, and seeing the one piece you've purchased as a moment within a larger practice. If you do that, it becomes fairly easy to distinguish the trend-followers from those whose work changes organically over time. In long run, I think the work that may be trend-aware but doesn't just follow trends is the one with staying power.

Anyway, great discussion!